Erickson Tribune

Top Stories

UPDATED: Monday, December 24, 2007

The courage to speak up

Posted on Friday, December 28, 2007
 

By Julia Boyle
THE ERICKSON TRIBUNE

More than two decades ago this month, Allan McDonald, 70, urged NASA officials to call off the Challenger’s launch. He directed the Space Shuttle Solid Rocket Motor Project for Morton Thiokol, Inc., the company that made the shuttle’s booster rockets.

He had listened intently to the Cape Canaveral weather forecast the night before the launch on January 28, 1986; he knew his rockets would fail.

Thiokol engineers expected the rockets’ seals (O-rings) to malfunction at low temperatures, and Cape weathermen forecasted temperatures below 20°F.

Yet, behind closed doors, someone made the decision to proceed. And McDonald and millions of Americans watched the Challenger explode in the sky the next morning.

Truth, Lies and O-Rings
This spring, McDonald plans to release his memoir on the incident and the decision to launch. Titled Truth, Lies and O-Rings: The Untold Story Behind the Challenger Accident, the book is co-authored by James R. Hansen.

Since the first Presidential Commission hearing regarding the Challenger explosion, McDonald recorded every detail from the investigation, the press coverage, and the shuttle’s redesign. “I knew who would be in the middle of all the litigation—me,” he says. “So I immediately decided I needed to write down everything that happened to me.”

McDonald says he wanted his book to be a real history about what really happened. “There have been a lot of books published about Challenger, but not one was written by a single person involved in it,” he says.

“I kept all those records, and when I retired in 2001, I had 1,400 handwritten  pages from the time [the Challenger explosion] happened to the return to flight,” he says. “I took that material and used it in writing the book.”

Lesson to be learned
As McDonald dug deeper in his research, he discovered a broader lesson—one that he hopes his readers will learn from his book (which he had originally intended to be used in engineering ethics classes).


Challenger

Top Stories
Image
More Top Stories

Does age matter?*

'We have the ability to make things better'

People make the place

Rudeness rising

Read or Add a Comment?

Car repair

Uninsured Motorist

Lyme Disease Story

Immigration

Creativity and the Brain!

How to Succeed in a Global Economy

Tools

Write a Comment on Story

Print

Email Story

Add to Favorites

“There were a dozen other engineers who supported my argument that night, but not one of them spoke up. In my discussions with many of them, I found that when management hears one or two people alone, they discount their opinion. Had the whole group said they didn’t support the decision to launch, I think that would have dramatically changed [management’s] minds,” he says.

“Everybody’s going to be wrong sometimes,” he adds, “but it’s your  professional responsibility to voice your opinion, right or wrong.”

Additional content
Raised in Montana, McDonald credits his parents with his ethics and his  decision to contest the launch. His co-author, Hansen, addresses those values in the biography section he wrote for the book. Titled “Big Sky Values,” the biography answers the question: Why did McDonald stand forward when everyone else stood back?

Through intensive interviews with McDonald, Hansen provides readers with an in-depth look at the man who tried to stop the Challenger explosion.

Aside from the biography and a traditional prologue and preface, Truth, Lies and O-Rings includes a review of nearly all of the other books written on the subject.


Allan McDonald on retirement

“I waited [to write Truth, Lies and ORings] until retirement because I held a very responsible position not only in the shuttle’s redesign, but I was also part of the flight readiness review board for the rest of my career. I didn’t feel comfortable writing about it until after I left my job,” McDonald says.

His job not only kept him from writing the memoir, but also from spending time with his family. “I worked a tremendous amount of overtime in redesigning the shuttle, and that was my therapy,” he says. “But I didn’t realize my three-year-old daughter was almost seven by the time it all ended.”

McDonald is now taking advantage of his retirement. “You can never retrieve lost time because your children will never be that age again, but I learned a great appreciation for having time available to me. Now, I make the decisions on what I want to do, when I want to do it,” he says. “That’s probably the greatest advantage of retirement: You’re in control of what you want to do.”



Click Here to Order Now!