Erickson Tribune


Top Stories

UPDATED: Tuesday, March 20, 2007

Organic foods-are they better for you?

Posted on Tuesday, March 13, 2007
 

By Shirley Siluk Gregory
THE ERICKSON TRIBUNE

No matter where you shop for groceries, chances are you’ve noticed a lot more “organic” labels cropping up on everything from strawberries to milk to breakfast cereals.

These organic items often come at higher prices than regular choices, in theory because they’re more healthful and better for you. But are they really? The answer, as with so many things, is, “It depends.”

Earning the label
To earn the “organic” label, food must comply with the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s standards for organic food production. These require crops to be raised without pesticides, synthetic fertilizers, genetic engineering, or ionizing radiation. Animals raised for organic milk, eggs, or meat must be fed organic foods with no growth-promoting antibiotics or hormones. And any food products— cereals, crackers, cookies, and so on—that are labeled “organic” must be made with at least 95% organic ingredients (only products made with nothing but organic ingredients can be labeled “100% organic”).

While the USDA says it “makes no claims that organically produced food is safer or more nutritious than conventionally produced food,” proponents of  organic eating point to research that might indicate otherwise.

Declining nutrient content
“Researchers have described a ‘dilution effect’ in which the nutrient content of dozens of fruits and vegetables has declined since 1950, as conventional farming methods have focused on increasing crop yields and producing products that look pretty and ship easily,” says Karen Perry Stillerman, senior analyst for the Food & Environment program at the Union of Concerned Scientists.

“In addition, a number of studies have directly compared the nutrient content of organic and conventional foods. Although this research is still in an early stage, there is evidence that organically grown foods tend to be higher in some nutrients, such as vitamin C and certain cancer-fighting antioxidants.”

Matt Tyler of the Organic Consumers Association concurs.


organicfood.jpg

Top Stories
Image
More Top Stories

Jobless claims jump unexpectedly to 16-year high

The New Frugality: Americans return to thriftiness

A rare ray of sunshine for shoppers: lower prices

UN: $7 billion needed for 2009 humanitarian work

Read or Add a Comment?

Car repair

Uninsured Motorist

Lyme Disease Story

Immigration

Creativity and the Brain!

How to Succeed in a Global Economy

Tools

Write a Comment on Story

Print

Email Story

Add to Favorites

He says, “According to a 2003 study in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, organic fruits and vegetables have significantly higher levels of cancer-fighting antioxidants, while a 2001 report by Britain’s Soil Association looked at 400 nutritional research studies and came to similar conclusions: foods grown organically had more minerals and vitamins.”

While organic foods might or might not be more nutritious than conventionally grown fruits, vegetables, grains, meat, or dairy products, they can reduce your chances of consuming the pesticides and other chemicals widely used in large-scale commercial farming. In studies by the Environmental Working Group (EWG), for example, many of the most common fruits and vegetables sold in supermarkets were found to have high levels of pesticide residues. Most of those residues can’t be removed simply by washing, and peeling robs away nutrients.

‘Dirty Dozen’
The “Dirty Dozen,” as the EWG calls them, include peaches, apples, sweet bell peppers, celery, nectarines, strawberries, cherries, pears, imported grapes, spinach, lettuce, and potatoes. “Eating the 12 most contaminated fruits and vegetables will expose a person to about 15 pesticides per day, on average,” the EWG states in its Shopper’s Guide to Pesticides in Produce  (www.ewg.org). “The best option is to eat a varied diet, wash all produce, and choose organic when possible to reduce exposure to potentially harmful  chemicals.”

Debate over pesticide exposure
What does this mean in terms of your health? There’s a lot of arguing over the long-term effects of consuming such chemicals. Some say the levels of pesticide exposure are so low, there’s no real health risk.

Others point to research that indicates some pesticides act as endocrine disruptors, meaning they alter our  bodies’ normal hormone signals.

“According to (the) EPA’s Guidelines for Carcinogen Risk Assessment,  children receive 50% of their lifetime cancer risks in the first two years of life,” Tyler says.

As for normal, healthy adults? Advocates of organic foods point out that, while it’s hard to link specific pesticides to specific illnesses or conditions, there’s no proof these chemicals aren’t potentially harmful. As EWG puts it, “Absence of knowledge is not proof of safety.”

“Because organic food has no preservatives, chemicals, irradiation, antibiotics, added hormones or genetically modified ingredients, it’s naturally going to be good for all of us, but will be even more beneficial to people with weakened immune systems,” says Diane Hatz, senior program director for Sustainable Table, which advocates for a more sustainable form of agriculture.

Environmentally friendly
Beyond reducing your potential exposure to pesticides, though, there’s another reason many people are choosing organic: it’s kinder to the environment.

“The more consumers choose organic, the fewer pesticides and synthetic  fertilizers will be applied to farm fields, and the fewer antibiotics will be fed to livestock,” says Stillerman of the Union of Concerned Scientists. “That means less air and water pollution and a healthier environment for us all. Organic farming also improves soil quality, ensuring a solid foundation for producing high-quality food for future generations.”

Organic alone, though, doesn’t guarantee that produce hasn’t been shipped cross-country or farther to make it to your supermarket. So organic grapes from Chile or organic clementines from South Africa aren’t necessarily fresh or less wasteful of fossil fuels.

Locally grown
“I tend to encourage people not to look specifically for organic food but to look for locally grown sustainable food,” says Sustainable Table’s Hatz. “Many small farmers gave up their organic certification when it became a federal program, yet they still farm using organic, or what we call ‘beyond organic,’ methods.”

What’s the ideal choice then? Your best bet will probably be your local farmer’s market: the produce won’t have traveled far, and—even if the fruits and vegetables aren’t labeled organic—many small growers are finding it’s good business to adopt environmentally sustainable practices.

To discuss this article, click here!


To learn more

USDA National Organic Program: http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/indexIE.htm

Organic Consumers Association: http://www.organicconsumers.org

Sustainable Table:  http://www.sustainabletable.org

 



Click Here to Order Now!