Erickson Tribune

Spirituality Today

UPDATED: Thursday, November 08, 2007

Women warned against Catholic ordination

Posted on Thursday, November 08, 2007
 
By CHERYL WITTENAUER
Associated Press Writer

ST. LOUIS (AP) — The St. Louis Archdiocese has warned two Roman Catholic women that they will be excommunicated if they are ordained as priests on Sunday.

Rose Marie Dunn Hudson, 67, and Elsie Hainz McGrath, 69, are set to be ordained by a former nun as part of the Roman Catholic Womenpriests movement that began in 2002.

Only men are ordained as priests and deacons in the Catholic Church. The Womenpriests and the advocacy group, the Women's Ordination Conference, are among Catholics pressing to change that tradition.

Both women said they will ignore Archbishop Raymond Burke's warning.

''It's a typically hierarchical form of intimidation, and we will not be intimidated,'' McGrath said.

The archdiocese declined to comment about the letters, delivered by courier to the women's homes Monday evening. In them, Burke warned the women they would be committing a ''grave error'' and ''act of schism'' by trying to receive priestly ordination.

He reminded them that the pope has stated infallibly that only men can receive a valid ordination, and wrote that ''in order to protect the faithful from grave spiritual deception'' if they go forward, they would ''incur automatically ... the censure of excommunication.''

Further, Burke wrote, ''additional disciplinary measures will also have to be imposed.''

''What is he going to do, burn us at the stake, or what?'' Hudson asked. ''We're going to just totally ignore it. This is not unexpected. We wondered why it took so long.''

Both women have graduate degrees in religious studies and have been active in ministry for years.

Hudson is a retired teacher who has done prison ministry for the past 15 years. McGrath is the widow of a Roman Catholic deacon and has worked for the archdiocese, for the theology department at St. Louis University and as a campus minister.


Spirituality Today
Image
More Spirituality Today

The roots of compassion

Many think God's intervention can revive the dying

He Sold His Soul on eBay(R)

Read or Add a Comment?

Jesus and violence

Discovering your Purpose in this World

god and suffering

Transcendent Bread: War Between Israel and Iran?

WHY THE BAPTISM IN THE HOLY SPIRIT

Charlestown Retirement center

Tools

Write a Comment on Story

Print

Email Story

Add to Favorites

Of the roughly 100 women who have been ordained as priests or deacons worldwide in the Womenpriests movement, including 37 in the U.S., only the first seven were officially excommunicated by the Vatican, said spokeswoman Bridget Mary Meehan. Others have received letters from their bishop like that sent by Burke, she said.

A former nun from South Africa who now lives in Germany is scheduled to ordain the women at a synagogue in St. Louis. Patricia Fresen, who has ordained other women, says she was ordained as a bishop in Germany in 2005 by an unnamed male bishop in good standing with the pope. She isn't recognized as a bishop by the church hierarchy.